My choice: Get the new, shiny, Canon S5-IS? It's bulkier than the Optio S4, but I can probably work with that...

lakmiseiru

If you get something big you probably still won't lug it around - plus it's likely more expensive and hence more worries about theft. Stick with the portable one you have - you said it best, "my best pictures are from situations where I wouldn't have *had* a DSLR on me..." All the folks I know who take photos as a major hobby (but not as their primary line of work) only carry their big cameras when they're planning on using them, and given that you take pictures unplanned it seems silly to have a big one and leave it at home all the time.

kyrandil

I was very happy with my S30, rather unhappy with my S70; which are both largish for a point-n-shoot. It's *barely* pocketable; but that was my criterion (as close as I can get to an SLR and still pocket)

jtu

It is hard to argue with convenient portability.

aletta

unless you can soak the additional expense of the big one getting broken sometimes.

ntn, jesse, peggusus, dbrunton, Ian, seph, milo, kevinr, perturbed, photon, shikoku88henro, jmorzins, Zadar, madcaptenor, paigep, karl