Doxory?

lakmiseiru: When referring to deities using pronouns... (comment with an explanation, please)

Asked 2 years ago

He/She/They

tibbetts
Best to stay on the safe side and not offend potential deities.
aletta
though, I think I only capitalize for my own deity.
Richie
If you think they are lowercase, why call them deities? Also, if I were to be so egoistic as to capitalize myself when using "I", I should think to capitalize supernal pronouns. :)
transistorman
i hear it's traditional, and also helps disambiguate subjects in a sentence.
hatter
It's what the style guide says, in most instances of $deity

beppu, peggusus, buddywiser36, crschmidt, way2tired, krellis, dobedobedoh, templar781, paigep, djdrue, helder, raloxifiend, garfieldfreak123, SeaofTeeth, erin, rowr_grl, HoodOrnament

he/she/they

seph
but I generally don't capitalize things anyhow.
jmorzins
How formal are your deities?
kyrandil
i never understood the whole uppercase pronoun thing anyway.
sauergeek
I've always thought it silly to capitalize pronouns for anyone or anything. Lower-case is standard.
gugod
what if god was one of us ?
quince
I tend to make an exception for the Christian/Jewish G_d out of habit, but not for god/gods in general, or figures such as Jesus or the Buddha.
Ian
I don't think I'd capitalize unless I was quoting some religious text that did so
susannah
I usually avoid using pronouns for my own god altogether. If I need to use something like himself/herself/their selves, I use 'Godself', which does look kind of kooky, but also makes you think about pronouns in that context. When I'm writing about deities in other religions, I use the lowercase pronouns with the appropriate gender and number; I think that capitalizing indicates reverence on the writer's part for the deity in question, which would be inappropriate if I'm not of that religion.
ManWorkingHere
I thought it was accepted English grammar to not capitalize other deities unless they started a sentence.
cshiley
Depends. What's the context? Are they your gods? Are you writing in the tradition, or outside of it? Descriptive or not? I generally do not cap pronouns for any deity unless I'm explicitly speaking within a context that assumes the existence and appropriate authority of the relevant deity. If I'm writing up a summary of a bible story, for instance, I'll cap Lord and God and He. If I'm talking about a bible story, I won't. Not that I'm entirely consistent in implementation. "and then Elijah called three times on the Lord, who made it rain again" vs "then Elijah prays to god, and bam, it rained."
androidqueen
I don't attribute anything particularly great to them.
Yoyo
You're not writing in German. Gratuitous capitalization feels too heavy.
stilvoid
Capital letters are for proper names.
ksil83
i think in an eastern religions class i took, we left them all uncapitalized.

jesse, nelhage, trs, Alex, chrisamaphone, ternus, ctl, Lattyware, madcaptenor, eisenbud, mitsa17, gradster1

Skipped (with comments)

ntn
Capitalize in directly religious text, but not in meta-analysis or non-religious stories (And yes, I know the distinction is hard to make)
gaal
Use the conventions your readers expect
geoff
If they're not your deities, rephrase to avoid if at all possible. IMHO, He/She/They is inappropriate except in the context of something you personally believe (it's making it *look like* you venerate the deity, but you don't actually follow through in real life, beyond the lip service); yet he/she/they is an implicit dis to believers who are of the opinion that their deity should always take the capital. You can't win. Taking other people's gods on your own terms is an inherently touchy thing. Exception: in hippy-dippy crunchy-granola feel-good universal earth love literature, just use He/She/They everywhere, even for rocks, blades of grass, etc. You might not go to mass but we know you venerate Him in your own way, star child.
shadow
It

If you make a stupid choice because a website tells you to, it's your own damn fault.